I have too much Star Wars paraphernalia. That much is obvious. For a 28 year old man to have an AT-AT walker in his bedroom is clearly a sign that something is wrong. But it’s not all my fault. A lot of the various Lucas-endorsed merchandise was given to me by well-meaning relatives who had absolutely no idea what to get me for Christmas. As I’m “too old” for toys, that means I generally get books related to the subject, meaning that my Star Wars library is far more extensive than I would like.
The thing about all these Star Wars books is that they throw up some really weird things. The last Star Wars book I got (and the one that forced me to declare a polite moratorium on any more Lucas Literature) was The Art of Star Wars Galaxy Volume 2. Now, given that I don’t own Volume 1, and that the strapline of the book reads “Based on the best-selling Topps trading card series!”, you might think that my well-meaning family had really reached the bottom of the barrel. I certainly thought so, which is why it took such a long time for me to even look inside the book.
I wasn’t missing much. Fantasy/sci-fi art is generally pretty dreadful and when was the last time you saw one of those trading cards and thought: “Mmm, I’d love to have a bigger print of that air-brushed portrait of a tusken raider” ? (I’m guessing never, but maybe that’s your thing.) Anyway, it was only when I got to page 90 when I noticed something really, really weird.

Now, what’s weird about this particular picture isn’t so much the art itself, but the message intended by the artist.
“Since I was in the military, I wanted to present these guys as soldiers,” explains illustrator Mike Mayhew. “I wanted just a taste of their humanity on display, a suggestion of real emotion as one of them begins to lose his helmet in a battle…”
Am I the only one who finds this strange? Why the hell are we suddenly getting all empathetic with the ruthless drones of the empire?
But perhaps he’s making some sort of pacifistic plea. Given the Stormtrooper’s infamous crapness in battle (bashing heads on doors, inability to shoot slow-moving droids mincing through corridors, being overpowered by little furry muppets brandishing twigs, the list goes on), perhaps Mr Mayhew is making a wider comment about the effectiveness of US foreign policy. Either way, the comparison doesn’t flatter any one.